If you’ve been dreaming of life in the Florida Keys—whether it’s a cozy getaway, a full-time home, or a smart investment—these six listings offer something for every kind of islander. From serene Sugarloaf Shores to the historic charm of Old Town Key West, let’s take a closer look.
🏡 180 Sugarloaf Drive – Tranquil Island Living
3 BD | 2 BA | $795,000
Set on a spacious 12,000 sq ft lot in desirable Sugarloaf Shores, this charming Florida Keys home invites you to relax and unwind. Highlights include a remodeled kitchen, screened porch, and a beautifully landscaped, fenced yard. There’s plenty of room for a pool, RV, or just soaking up the sun. Ideal for full-time living, a weekend retreat, or vacation rental.
📸 
📸
📞 Jenny Perry 305-747-0369 | Angela McChesney 305-395-2540
🏡 1312 Catherine Street – Classic Duplex Near Bayview Park
2 Units | 1 BD / 1 BA Each | $980,000
Located just steps from White Street and Bayview Park, this well-maintained duplex offers two 1BD/1BA units, each with private entries, outdoor spaces, and in-unit laundry. Off-street parking, gated storage, and lush landscaping make it move-in ready. Live in one, rent the other—or invest in a strong rental property.
📸 
📸 
📞 Laura McChesney 305-923-6639
🏡 3741 Eagle Avenue – Elegant Modern Construction with Guest Cottage
3 BD | 3.5 BA + Guest Cottage | $4,400,000
This newly constructed concrete home is a showstopper. Sitting on a 10,800 sq ft lot at 10.5 ft elevation, it features soaring ceilings, two en-suite primaries, impact doors, a chilled/heated pool, coral rock outdoor shower, and a garage. The guest cottage is perfect for guests or extended family. Whole-house generator included—just bring your bags!
📸 
📸 
📞 Angela McChesney 305-395-2540 | Jenny Perry 305-747-0369
🏡 1616 Atlantic Blvd. #5 Oceanfront Townhome Community
2 BD | 2.5 BA | $1,788,900
Located in an exclusive 20-unit, gated, owner-occupied community, this townhome is a true rarity. Enjoy ocean views or glimpses from all four balconies, extra side garden space, and a second parking spot. Interior is bright and breezy with sliding glass doors and multiple outdoor living areas. A peaceful retreat just minutes from everything.
📸
📸 
📞 Mabry Binnicker 305-304-5624
🏡 318 Margaret Street – Old Town Charm Meets Modern Comfort
2 BD | 2 BA | $1,390,000
Nestled in the Historic Seaport District, this beautifully updated Conch house is full of personality. Inside, you’ll find a smart split floor plan, granite kitchen, hardwood and tile floors, and modern amenities like a heated pool, whole-house generator, outdoor shower, and temp-controlled storage. Bonus: Off-street parking and easy walkability to shops, restaurants, and your boat.
📸 
📸 
📞 Phil Lavoie 317-292-4423 | Jose Wenzel 305-395-1381
🏡 48 Merganser Lane – “Sweet Tee” in the Key West Golf Club
2 BD | 1.5 BA | $689,000
Welcome to “Sweet Tee,” a cheerful two-story townhome tucked into the quiet Key West Golf Club community. This home has proven vacation rental success and includes access to two pools, a fitness center, and lush green space. Enjoy a relaxed island lifestyle just minutes from Old Town, beaches, and top dining.
📸 
📸 
📞 Phil Lavoie 317-292-4423 | Jose Wenzel 305-395-1381
💻 For more details or to schedule a showing, visit us at PreferredPropertiesKeyWest.com
Leave a Reply