🏝️ Island Living Opportunities: From Old Town to Sugarloaf Shores
Posted by Preferred Properties Key West
Dreaming of your own slice of paradise? From charming midtown cottages to cutting-edge contemporary homes and unique investment opportunities, these Florida Keys properties showcase the best of island living. Explore the details below — each offers something special for every buyer.
📍 2016 Fogarty Avenue, Key West
Located in the heart of Midtown, this charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath home offers classic island style on a generous 50′ x 100′ lot with plenty of room for a pool. Inside, you’ll find beautiful wood floors, a bright and comfortable living area, and a convenient washer and dryer. Enjoy off-street parking, a large storage shed, and lush tropical surroundings.
Perfect as a primary residence, rental investment, or weekend retreat, this property offers an excellent opportunity to create your own Key West oasis just minutes from beaches, shopping, and Old Town. Corky Irick 305-923-1744
🌿 2109 Seidenberg Avenue, Key West
Tropical charm, flexible living, and a fantastic location — welcome to 2109 Seidenberg Avenue in the heart of New Town. This updated 3-bedroom, 2-bath home includes a separate, fully equipped guest cottage, perfect for friends, family, or extended stays.
Highlights include beautiful hardwood floors, remodeled kitchen with stainless steel appliances, hurricane impact windows and doors, and a brand-new roof (July 2024). The lush yard features tropical landscaping, a mango tree, and inviting porches. Comes fully furnished (minus a few personal paintings), ready to enjoy from day one. Mike and Elise Irwin 305-509-2149
🏡 180 Sugarloaf Drive, Sugarloaf Shores – Motivated Sellers!
Set on an oversized 12,000 sq. ft. lot, this charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath home is fenced for privacy and offers plenty of room for a pool, boat, or RV. You’ll love the remodeled kitchen, bonus screened porch, outdoor shower, and lush gardens. The warm, inviting interior makes it ideal as a full-time residence, weekend getaway, or investment with room to grow. Easy to show — call today! Key West Sisters
✨ Contemporary Luxury in Truman Annex – 115 Front Street #101, Key West, FL
Once a historic Naval base, Truman Annex now features some of Key West’s most coveted real estate. This newly renovated 3-bedroom, 3-bath home blends classic charm with modern luxury by designer David Smith.
Enjoy soaring ceilings, exposed ductwork, geometric lighting, and full smart home automation. The chef’s kitchen boasts illuminated crystalline quartz countertops, premium Miele appliances, and sleek walnut cabinetry. Bathrooms are spa-inspired with quartz sinks, multi-head showers, and smart toilets.
Additional features include impact windows, blackout shades, designer finishes, and a covered deeded parking space. Offered fully furnished and turnkey with a transient license valid through the end of 2025. Key West Luxury Finders
🪴 Prime Vacant Lot – Old Town, Key West, 416 Applerouth Lane
A rare opportunity to build your dream home in a vibrant, historic community. This transient receiver site allows the possibility of one residential and one commercial unit, offering endless potential in the heart of Old Town. Key West Sisters
Jenny Perry 305-747-0369 and Angela McChesney 305-395-2540
🌅 Transferable Transient ROGO Allocation
An exceptional opportunity for hotel, inn, or vacation rental owners between Stock Island and Tavernier Key. This transferable Transient ROGO Allocation allows you to:
-
Increase your permitted room count
-
Legalize an unpermitted “ghost room”
-
Enhance operational capacity and long-term resale value
With transient ROGOs in extremely limited supply, this allocation can save you from costly delays. Fully transferable and ready for immediate use — contact us today for details. Corky Irick 305-923-1744
📞 Ready to Explore Island Living?
Whether you’re looking for a tropical retreat, a family home, or an investment opportunity, the agents at Preferred Properties Key West are here to help you find your perfect match.
Leave a Reply