🌴 Own the Entire Lighthouse View Condominium – A Hidden Gem in Old Town Key West!
📍 919 Thomas Street, Units #A, #1, #2, and #3
💰 Offered at $3,999,000
📞 Listed by Mabry Binnicker | 305-304-5624
Tucked away in one of the most original neighborhoods in Old Town, this unique offering includes all four units of the Lighthouse View Condominium Association—a lush, gated compound brimming with character, privacy, and endless potential.
Currently configured as four high-performing long-term rentals, this property is a rare investment opportunity or the perfect multi-family retreat.
🏡 The Main Residence – A Private Sanctuary
Located at the rear of the property, the main home is a private paradise, featuring its own heated pool, bubbling hot tub, and expansive brick terrace surrounded by tropical gardens.
Inside, a freestanding two-story building houses a beautiful great room and half bath downstairs, and a sunny master suite upstairs with cathedral ceilings, skylight, and serene garden views.
🏡 Two Guest Cottages with Island Charm
Adjacent to the main residence are two charming guest cottages, each with 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom, and their own welcoming front porches. A shared deck connects the cottages and includes an outdoor wet bar, perfect for entertaining, plus an outdoor shower for rinsing off after a dip in the pool.
🏡 Additional Residences in the Front Building
At the front of the property, you’ll find three more beautifully maintained units:
-
Two 1BR/1BA units on the lower level
-
A stylish 2BR/1BA unit upstairs, complete with a spacious private deck shaded by mature trees
Each residence is filled with natural light and offers the charm and comfort that renters—and owners—love.
🚲 Gated Entry, Parking & Extras
Enter through the electric gate to a brick-paved courtyard with parking for multiple vehicles and ample space for bicycles. A covered carport provides even more convenience. With thoughtful touches and tropical landscaping throughout, this compound is a true Key West original.
✨ Investment Potential + Island Lifestyle
Whether you’re looking for a private family compound, luxurious guest retreat, or a proven income-producing property, Lighthouse View Condominium delivers. Opportunities like this are incredibly rare in Old Town—don’t let it slip away! This is a pedestrian friendly neighborhood, located a few blocks from Blue Heaven Restaurant.
📞 Ready to schedule a showing? Contact Mabry Binnicker at 305-304-5624.
🌐 Discover more unique Key West properties at Preferred Properties Key West
Leave a Reply